Pudgie's Pizzeria

Welcome to Pudgie's Pizzeria, a beloved gem nestled in the heart of Rochester, NY, located at 1753 N Goodman St. Known for its warmth, charm, and a family-friendly atmosphere, Pudgie's has been delighting taste buds for years with its irresistible pizza and inviting service.

As you step inside, you're greeted by the melodious tunes and a cozy ambiance that makes it an ideal spot for families and friends alike. The moment you arrive, an attentive staff member is ready to help you navigate the extensive menu, which features everything from classic cheese pies to satisfying meatball subs. Many visitors echo the sentiment of Josiane Mbonimpaye, who noted the kindness and patience of the employees, making it a pleasant experience for her and her daughters.

  • Signature Pizza: The pizzas here are truly a standout. With an airy, light crust that boasts a satisfying crunch, you'll find the perfect harmony of sauce and cheese, as noted by Alison O'Connell. Whether it's pepperoni, veggie, or a custom creation, each slice is crafted with fresh ingredients and a passion that resonates with the local community.
  • Delicious Wings: Don’t miss Pudgie's traditional wings that come with ample sauce and blue cheese at no extra charge. They have quickly become a favorite among regulars like Erica Michelle, who loved her wing and pizza combo, declaring the overall experience “pretty good.”
  • Variety of Offerings: Beyond pizza, the menu doesn't skimp on variety. You can easily grab a quick slice, take home a full meal, or venture into other offerings like mozzarella sticks and cheesecake. All these options keep customers excited about their next visit.

Many patrons, such as Stephani Michelle, have been coming to Pudgie's for years, affirming its consistent quality and friendly service. The restaurant is not just a place to eat; it embodies a nostalgic experience that visitors cherish, whether they are long-time locals or first-time travelers like Marina Beregovsky.

With competitive prices to boot, Pudgie's Pizzeria proves to be an exceptional dining choice, resonating with all who walk through its doors. As Jose emphasizes, the quality of pizza and the staff's friendliness create a memorable experience that invites repeat visits — a sentiment echoed by many happy customers.

So, if you find yourself in Rochester, make sure to carve out some time for Pudgie's Pizzeria. With the promise of delicious food, great service, and a welcoming atmosphere, it's an experience you won't soon forget!

For more information, feel free to call +1 585-266-6605 or simply stop by and indulge in what many believe to be the best pizza in town!

Menu

Location

Address: 1753 N Goodman St, Rochester, NY 14609, United States
Phone: +1 585-266-6605

🕓 Work Hours
MON Closed
TUE 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM
WED 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM
THU 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM
FRI 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM
SAT 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM
SUN Closed

Business info

  • Wheelchair-accessible Car Park
    Yes
  • Wheelchair-accessible Entrance
    Yes
  • Wheelchair-accessible Seating
    Yes
  • Wheelchair-accessible Toilet
    Yes
  • Offers Takeaway
    Yes
  • Serves Dine-in
    Yes
  • Popular For Lunch
    Yes
  • Popular For Dinner
    Yes
  • Good For Solo Dining
    Yes
  • Serves Comfort Food
    Yes
  • Serves Halal Food
    Yes
  • Serves Late-night Food
    Yes
  • Quick Bite
    Yes
  • Serves Small Plates
    Yes
  • Serves Vegan Dishes
    Yes
  • Serves Brunch
    Yes
  • Serves Lunch
    Yes
  • Serves Dinner
    Yes
  • Catering
    Yes
  • Serves Dessert
    Yes
  • Seating
    Yes
  • Toilet
    Yes
  • Casual
    Yes
  • Cosy
    Yes
  • Historic
    Yes
  • Trendy
    Yes
  • Good For Groups
    Yes
  • Popular With Tourists
    Yes
  • Popular With University Students
    Yes
  • Doesn't Accept Reservations
    Yes
  • Accepts Credit Cards
    Yes
  • Accepts Debit Cards
    Yes
  • Accepts NFC Mobile Payments
    Yes
  • Credit Cards
    Yes
  • Good For Kids
    Yes
  • High Chairs Available
    Yes
  • Kids' Menu
    Yes
  • Free Of Charge Street Parking
    Yes
  • Free Parking Lot
    Yes
  • Plenty Of Parking
    Yes

Last Reviews

  • Author: Josiane Mbonimpaye

    04 June 2025

    It was my first time visiting this place .After a long day, I drove to Prugie’s Pizza on N Goodman st with my daughters. They enjoyed ordering pizza and choosing their favorite toppings. The employee was very kind and patient with both me and my kids. He answered all our questions and explained the different options available. The ambiance and music created a peaceful atmosphere. From my kids' perspective, the food was a "chef’s kiss," and I couldn't agree more. we will be coming back once a month.

  • Author: Stephani Michelle

    29 May 2025

    I don't know where to start. Pudgie's has been around for years and never disappoints. I've always said how you guys would definitely make a killing if you delivered. On the flip side the food is so good it's worth going to pick up. The entire staff here is wonderful. They basically watched me grow up Food is always fresh and the pizza is amazing. Absolutely Recommend

  • Author: Latoya Gill

    24 May 2025

    First time here in Rochester very good pizza and hospitality! Would definitely recommend

  • Author: Erica Michelle

    21 May 2025

    I got a large pepperoni pizza and 20 traditional wings. They give you extra sauce and blue cheese free of charge. They also have already made pizza and chicken wings. If you just wanna run in there and grab a slice, they also have ice cream salad, cheesecake, fresh baked goods which I will be trying next time. Overall it was pretty good. I can’t wait to go back and get some ice cream. And the prices are reasonable and they have a full menu. like mozzarella sticks, steak subs, and a bunch of other items.